Players whose Italian ethnicity is in doubt, but are considered by some to be Italian-American. If you have further information on these player’s heritage, please comment on it below…
To view each of these players’ page in turn, start here then look for the above “doubtful” icon on each page to advance to the next player – or go directly to individual player’s pages through links below:
| Mussina, Mike | Not Italian American |
| Carbo, Bernie | Unlikely |
| Bevacqua, Kurt | Not Italian American |
| Tinker, Joe | Probably Italian American |
| Maloney, Jim | Unlikely |
| LaPorte, Frank | Unlikely |
| Robello, Tony | Unlikely |
| Demaree, Al | Unlikely |
| Barna, Babe | Unlikely |
| Broaca, Johnny | Not Italian American |
| Fonseca, Lew | Unlikely |
| Banta, Jack | Unlikely |
| Dickerson, Buttercup | Unlikely |
| Cafego, Tom | Unlikely |
| Senzatela, Antonio | Probably Italian American |
| Balenti, Mike | Unlikely |
| Duffalo, Jim | Not Italian American |
| Pico, Jeff | Not Italian American |
| Serna, Paul | Not Italian American |
| Susce, George Sr | Unlikely |
| Susce, George Jr | Unlikely |
| Gura, Larry | Not Italian American |
| Tarasco, Tony | Probably Italian American |
Visit a random Italian American MLB player:
Landing